Studies
carried out on male and female bullies in schools and my own
observations of abusers show a startling similarity between the two.
This has led me to the conclusion that an abuser, whether male or
female, is simply a bully who never grew out of it.
As I am here
to speak about female abuse I will concentrate most of my remarks in
this area. I am aware that many of the techniques I am describing
here can apply to both male and female abusers however, there are
techniques that are almost exclusively female and I would like to
begin by examining these.
What are the
differences between male and female perpetrators that we all need to
be aware of if we are to make any serious attempt to understand
domestic violence for all people?
While there
are exceptions to every rule, the following can be useful as a
guideline.
Male
perpetrators will tend to try and isolate their victims by driving
off friends and family.
Female
perpetrators will tend do the exact opposite. She will gather
supporters around her and manipulate them into taking part in her
abuse. Her supporters and Co-abusers may be friends, family members,
authorities, or even her own children. Her techniques will include:
The
destruction of the reputations of her victims. This is usually
done in the first instance by carrying out a whispering campaign of
false and malicious allegations amongst close friends of the
perpetrator. This campaign is then broadened to friends of the
victim. This has the effects of destroying the victims credibility
and making the victim feel surrounded by hostility. The abuser has
gathered a "gang" of supporters. The manipulation of the gang is
often through seeking sympathy for some false charge against the
abuser or, by telling gang members the victim has/or is planning, to
do something against one or more members of the gang. Another
technique is to discover what the victim loves to do and set out to
destroy it. In the case of where the victim enjoys making or
collecting things, for example. Personal damage to property is very
common, or turning others against the victim so the victim can no
longer participate in their chosen hobby or activity.
Vocal
attacks. Having set the scene with the whispering campaign, the
abuser and those she has manipulated now begin to vocalise their
accusations. Often the stream of accusations will be deeply personal
and tailored to create maximum fear in the victim. A male victim of
this attack, for example, may be accused of being a child molester or
rapist. He may be accused of attempting to start an affair with
someone else's partner. Getting him fired from his job is another
technique reported by victims. Even personal family members can be
duped by female abusers into believing the "real" abuser is the
victim.
Violent
attacks. The female abuser will use violence in several different
ways. She will often manipulate others to attack the victim on her
behalf. This may involve angering other males with false allegations
( "He [the victim] said he wants to have sex with your little
daughter. He said he is going to attack you one night when you come
home from work. He said you are a homosexual," etc..). It may take
the form of personal physical attacks on the victim; trying to goad
him into hitting her so that charges will be brought. It may take the
form of a false allegation to the police such as a rape allegation,
child molestation allegation, etc.. Though not physically violent,
these allegations, where they are false, are certainly violent in
nature and are calculated to bring maximum fear and distress to the
victim. Paying others to hurt her victim is also a means by which
female abusers attack their partners, as is the administration of
toxic or poisonous substances. Spitting into food is very common. One
abusive female told me how she bought a can of dog meat, made a pie
and served it to her husband because, "I hated the bastard."
Victims
report commonly that they are ambushed by their abusers. Men are
often violently attacked when they are sleeping, sitting on the
toilet, have their backs turned to the victim, have children in their
arms and are thus rendered powerless to defend themselves. The
throwing of hot liquids such as fat, boiling water, coffee and tea
etc.., are also reported often. Other weapons include; baseball bats,
knives, forks, garden implements, pieces of wood or metal, household
furniture items, car jack handles, plates and cups being thrown,
etc.. Sexual abuse of their victim are also more common than people
believe and I have suffered personally from this kind of abuse.
Using
children to abuse males. This is by far one of the most common
and disgusting forms of abuse there is and it is an almost
exclusively female form of abuse. Though there are always exceptions
to every rule, the exceptions in this case are rare indeed.
All abusers,
irrespective of gender, seek control over their victims. They
actively look for things in the lives of their victims that are
vulnerable to attack. For female abusers, the bond between a father
and his children is a natural target for abuse. It is the one target
that can reduce a man to a shadow of his former self within weeks. It
can cement the abusers need for domination over her victim so solidly
and so completely that he will do anything she desires of him and, if
he is unable to satisfy her, it may even lead to murder or suicide.
When I read stories in the press or see television reports of a man
who has suddenly snapped and killed himself, his ex wife/partner
and/or the children I am often struck by the comments of those who
knew the man in question. Let me quote here from a recent report in
the Guardian Newspaper.
"The
Guardian
Friends
and relatives were last night comforting a mother whose estranged
husband killed himself and their four young sons in a fume-filled car
on a Welsh mountain pass early yesterday.
Keith
Young, a 38-year-old builder, collected the boys, all under eight, on
an access visit from the family home in Winsford, Cheshire. He drove
to the Horseshoe Pass, near Llangollen, where he appears to have used
a petrol-driven lawnmower to fill his Mitsubishi Shogun with carbon
monoxide fumes."
On the face
of it this is a terrible story of a heartless murdering father. I
have little doubt that some sections of the domestic violence
industry will joyfully point to it as a good reason to prevent all
men ever getting access to children. However, lets read on and look a
little closer at this tragic story. I have taken the liberty of re
arranging the story for the purposes of this talk but I have printed
a copy of the original for you all if you need it.
"Mr
Young's wife, Samantha, called the police just after midnight after
he phoned her and threatened to harm himself and his sons, Joshua,
seven, Thomas, six, Callum, five, and David, three."
The report
goes on:
"Friends
and neighbours in the cul-de-sac where the boys and their mother
lived remembered Mr Young as a devoted father.
"Keith
idolised those children - he used to take them around the fields on
his tractor while he was at work," said Tom Challoner, a family
friend. "He was a kind and loving father. But he took the
break-up of his marriage really hard and it changed him.
"He
sank into a fog of depression. He loved his kids so much and couldn't
cope not seeing them every day.
"They
were really, really polite and friendly boys. I would see them most
days playing in the street and they would always say hello. It's such
a tragedy and has really shocked everybody here. There is nothing
that can be done to change anything but we'll all be here for Sam -
she's going to be devastated..."
This is very
interesting.
"Friends
and neighbours in the cul-de-sac where the boys and their mother
lived remembered Mr Young as a devoted father..." And,
"Keith
idolised those children - he used to take them around the fields on
his tractor while he was at work," said Tom Challoner, a family
friend.
And, "He was a kind and loving father..."
And, "...He loved his kids so much..."
And, "...It's so not like him, he was a wonderful man."
These are not
the descriptions of some lunatic man full of violence and hatred for
women. Further into the report we read, "The elder boys attended
Handley Hill primary school in Winsford. A young mother, who has a
daughter attending the same school, said: "Keith and Sam seemed
the perfect parents and they always appeared happy together at school
functions such as plays and sports days."
What about
the children themselves? Any evidence that they were brought up
badly?
"They
were really, really polite and friendly boys. I would see them most
days playing in the street and they would always say hello..."
This was
obviously, to all external appearances, a devoted father and family
man. But something was very wrong in this marriage. Something was
happening to him that drove him over the edge and sent a normal well
balanced man into a tail spin that resulted in a very desperate act.
"I
can't begin to imagine how the children's mother must be feeling,"
Said, "Bill Brereton, Deputy Chief Constable of the North Wales
force..."
"Her
whole life has been ripped away from her in one stroke. I can't
understand why Keith would do this to her and himself..." said
Tom Challoner, a neighbour. He went on, "There is nothing that
can be done to change anything but we'll all be here for Sam - she's
going to be devastated."
Another
neighbour said, "I'll never be able to understand why Keith
would do such a thing, but he has, and I'm very angry with him,"
she said. "How could he put poor Sam through this? He was always
well-liked in Winsford and also well-known. This is just madness. It
doesn't feel real - my heart really goes out to Samantha."
So, what
drove a normal well balanced man to lose control so badly that he
killed himself and his children? The answer is the terrible pain of
separation from them. His friend, Tom Challoner put his finger on it
when he said, "He was a kind and loving father. But he took
the break-up of his marriage really hard and it changed him. He sank
into a fog of depression. He loved his kids so much and couldn't cope
not seeing them every day."
This is the
kind of powerful bond a man can develop with his kids. It is
identical to the bond a mother has with them. A mans wife and
children can be his whole life. His whole reason for getting up in
the morning and trudging to work. His whole reason for going off to
war and putting his life on the line to defend them. Losing your wife
or partner can be devastating for a man but, to then be ripped away
from your children also can often be too much to bear.
There are no
counselling services offered to parents who suddenly lose contact
with their kids.
Abusers are
well aware of this fatherly bond and the power of it. The bond is the
perfect target and yes, they will often do all they can to destroy
it. Just threatening to destroy it is often enough to guarantee a
compliant victim. What is often even harder to bear is watching an
abusive female turning the hearts of the children against the father.
Is it any wonder that some men, isolated from help and support,
having no place to go with the kids, snap and become violent,
suicidal, or even murder?
Manipulation of the authorities.
A sobbing
female who appears to be in great distress can have a powerful effect
on police officers and judges etc.. Female abusers are very aware of
this. They will change from aggressive abusers to helpless looking
"victims" at the drop of a hat. Untrained police officers etc.
will easily be taken in. Tragically, this can result in the victim
being arrested and removed from the house while the children are left
behind with a female abuser. This is why hostels for men to go to
with their children while abuse allegations are investigated are so
vital. Equally vital is the need to train policemen and women, social
workers, battered wives hostel staff, doctors, council domestic
violence officers, teachers in schools, hospital staff etc., to learn
to recognise the techniques of female abusers and the typical
injuries they often inflict upon their victims.
A woman I
have met who claimed her husband tortured and beat her daily for over
5 years aroused my suspicions when I noted an absence of a fear
response large enough to justify such horrific accusations. She
should have exhibited huge symptoms of distress to accompany the
allegations she claimed were less than six months old.
When I
separated her from the children and questioned them alone, they all
reported that they had never seen evidence of the abuse the woman
claimed was taking place. I asked them if they had seen bruising,
black eyes, heard their mother screaming at night etc.. Without a
single exception the children reported that no such thing had ever
been witnessed by them all. They all stated that they hated the ex
husband but further questioning revealed that this was because they
had been programmed to hate him by their mother. None of the children
reported being abused by him and only one of them said the father had
physically punished him after he had had a temper tantrum. Even so,
this woman was granted custody almost as a matter of right.
Commonalties
with abusers, both male and female, also appear.
Within
abusive relationships men report that female abusers are incredibly
skilled at emotional and mental destruction of their victims.
Constant false or exaggerated accusations can leave the victim
feeling disoriented, confused, angry, fearful and depressed. This is
amplified when the abuser has manipulated others into joining in with
this abuse. Another technique that has been observed is the abuser
will constantly criticise everything the victim tries to do with
respect to the home, children, personal habits, work related matters,
handling of money, personal appearance, hobbies and interests,
friends, sexual performance, D.I.Y, personal tastes such as art,
movies, television programs and on and on. The list is almost
endless.
Personal
verbal attacks that are designed to rob the victim of confidence are
also very common. The victim will told over and over again that he is
useless at anything he tries to do. Phrases such as, "Men are all
stupid." "Men are all bastards." "Men only want one thing."
Become personalised into, "You are stupid." "You are a
bastard." Etc. There is some anecdotal evidence to suggest that the
abuser is picking up these phrases from television soap operas,
magazine articles, etc.., and using them as ammunition to destroy
her victim. It would seem that the abuser is justifying herself by
thinking that if society tolerates these sexist remarks against men
there must be validity in her using them. However, she fails to see
that by personalising them in this way she is being abusive.
Constant
lying and deceit is another common theme male victims report.
Destruction
of personal property.
The abuser
will empty a bank account or deliberately damage a vehicle so that it
cannot be legally driven. Clothing will be destroyed. Spectacles are
destroyed. All techniques to prevent the victim being able to escape,
or continue working, or socialising. I have personally known a female
abuser who once had a friend who ran a scrap yard, remove her
husbands vehicle and crush it. She then had the cubed remains of the
vehicle dumped in his garden as a warning not to defy her in future.
She feels utterly safe in boasting about this behaviour. She claims
her husband was abusive to her and thus "deserved" it. She also
broke several of his bones by encouraging him to get drunk and then,
as he slept, attacking him with a baseball bat before setting the
house on fire. When the fire brigade turned up and asked if anyone
else was in the house she replied, "Only the cat." Her feeling of
utter safety in talking openly about these appalling incidents is a
sad reflection of our legal systems utter refusal to act against
these women or, when they do act, to believe everything they say and
let them escape punishment. (The woman who broke her husbands bones
and set the house alight was never investigated or charged.) In fact,
in some cases, female violence of the most extreme nature has been
openly and publicly rewarded by senior members of the government.
This leaves male victims feeling even more isolated and fearful while
at the same time encouraging female perpetrators of domestic violence
to be ever more bold.
The
destruction of personal documents such as birth certificates,
passports, photographs of loved ones, heirlooms, drivers licences and
medical prescriptions is very common.
Threats
A common
theme that male victims report are when the abuser makes threats to
involve them in legal fights that will bankrupt them and cause them
to lose their business or home if they do not conform to the abusers
wishes. These threats may be anything from blackmail to removing the
children to another country. A common threat is to turn the victim
out of the house by falsely reporting abusive behaviour to the
police. Using children as weapons of abuse is extraordinarily common.
Self harming, false rape allegations, simulating fear of the victim
and then calling the police are also reported techniques. Again, I
have personally witnessed this form of abuse.
A man who
lives very close to me was subjected to a verbal attack that went on
for at least 2.5 hours in my hearing. During which he was called,
fat, stupid, lazy, thick, useless, crap in bed, a fucking wanker,
etc.., etc.. His wife then told him she wanted him out of the house.
(They have bought the house from the council). When he refused to
leave she said to him, "Right. I will call the police and they will
chuck you out!" He laughed and said, "They can't do that." She
replied, "Just you wait and see." I then heard her call the
police on her mobile phone and say, "It's my husband. I want him
out. I just can't take anymore of him. There was a pause and she
said, "Yes, he is abusive." After making the call, she then
shouted at her husband, "Don't think you will see the kids every
weekend either cos I will see to it you never fucking see them!" In
due course two police cars arrived. She then began crying and told
the police officers she was frightened of her husband. They ordered
him to pack a suitcase and leave the home. He did so quietly. While
he was packing his case I managed to slip a note to one of the
officers that contained the truth of what had taken place. The
officer read the note but made no effort to stop proceedings and the
husband was removed from his home and child. The whole argument was
over the man asking his wife to return five pounds she had borrowed
from him a week earlier. In a very real sense this unfortunate man
was abused twice. Once by his wife and then again, by the police. The
man in question is now back with his wife but he has learned not to
answer back when she gets upset. She now has what all abusers want,
total control over the victim. He knows, almost instinctively, that
he is powerless and no one will listen to him.
Men's
failure to report their abuse.
Most men
never report the abuse they are suffering to the police or anyone
else in authority and why would they? Those who have tried it before
them find themselves subject to a wall of disbelief, incredulity or
even, disparaging remarks from whoever answers the telephone at the
police station or social services department. Some men, unable to
find anything in the telephone directory in the form of help lines
for male victims, have called Women's Aid organisations or hostels
and been told, "We don't help men." Sometimes other male friends
will laugh at them and call them wimps if they tell them about their
experiences.. Hitting her would almost certainly call at least a
temporary halt to her abuse but it may also result in arrest, loss of
the home and all contact with the children. It may even cost him his
livelihood. Furthermore, abusive females are noted for their sense of
revenge. It may even cost him his life.
If he leaves
the home and takes any children he may have with him, he could easily
find himself on the end of a kidnapping charge and see his face
splashed over the national press.
Everyone from
doctors to politicians, policemen to social workers, often appear
deaf to male victims in almost all cases. When I reported my
incredibly painful and humiliating sexual abuse to my female doctor
she shrugged her shoulders and replied, "Why are you telling me
this?" Her dismissive tone left me in doubt that she did not care
in the slightest. Had I been a female reporting the same abuse I
would be willing to wager she would have reached for the telephone
and immediately called the police.
As a further
example of bias in the official caring agencies let me speak about an
ongoing case.
I am
currently trying to help a father in Liverpool. His wife has been
tried and convicted for assaulting him. His wife's mother has been
convicted of harassment. He has received over 100 abusive text
messages. Hundreds of threatening and abusive telephone calls which
have all been logged by BT and taped by him. His children have
suffered nightmares and constantly tell their father they are
frightened of going to stay with their mother. His ex wife has beaten
the male child so badly that he had to have medical attention. He is
6 years old. She has taunted the 11 year old vegetarian daughter by
throwing fur coats at her and telling her to put them on. The little
girl has been forced to eat meat against her will. His ex wife had
told the father she wants to, "have him killed." And he has the
threat on tape. Despite all of this, the local social services
department, led by a female social worker, are doing everything they
can to have the children removed from the father and handed over to
the abusive mother through the courts because, "A child belongs
with its mother." The incident of the child being beaten was
downplayed, and re-described as, "inappropriate punishment" in
the court welfare report. Would you report your abuser if you faced
this kind of institutional sexism and, frankly, abusive behaviour by
the organisation that is supposed to protect the interests of your
kids?
The
literature that spills out of government organisations talking about
domestic violence is often slanted towards the female victim only. It
is filled with helpful advice, telephone numbers of support
organisations and practical things to be done to help women and
children to escape the abuse. Nothing will be written that is aimed
at men or addresses their needs. Though the text of the document may
appear to be gender neutral -- and this is by no means certain -- the
advice and contact section will leave no doubt that it is not for
men.
Local council
web sites are often just as bad.
Government
spokesmen such as Jack Straw constantly make statements that are
deeply offensive to male victims such as, "Domestic violence is men
hitting women."
The actual
numbers of male victims as revealed in scientific surveys carried out
over a thirty year period show, again and again, that there is near
parity between males and females in the numbers of abuse victims. Yet
every possible effort is made by women's groups, politicians and the
police in some cases, local council officials and on and on, to down
play the importance of the studies and their findings. In fact, even
the authors of the studies have come under threats of both a personal
and professional nature just for having the nerve to publish them.
The manner in which the studies have been carried out has been
attacked. When the researchers changed the way they gathered the
information the new way was attacked. Yet these same people will
believe, without question, every single statistic pumped out by every
women's group on the amount of female victims there are. Despite the
fact that these statistics are often utterly false and at best
misleading, on the basis of them, millions of pounds are poured into
improving services for female victims while men and the elderly are
virtually ignored.
Author and
campaigner Erin Pizzey who opened the worlds first domestic violence
shelter for women, also opened one for men. Funds poured into the
female shelter, the men's hostel got nothing. When she wrote a book
entitled, "Prone To Violence" that explores the fact that females
can be violent too, she was threatened so seriously that her mail had
to be opened by the bomb squad. She had to have a police escort when
she gave talks and finally, she was forced to flee the country. Book
stores were warned by anonymous callers not to put her book on the
shelf or they would be burned down. In America, where she carried on
her work, she suffered the same persecution for daring to suggest
that women are violent too and, when her dog was shot and left on her
doorstep on Christmas morning as a warning to keep silent, she
returned to England. All of this was done by caring, sharing, female
domestic violence workers and women's organisations who say that
females are not violent!
None of this
is conducive to giving male victims the confidence to report their
abusers.
Abusive
females, as we have already seen, often know the law as well as
anyone. If the victim leaves the home she only has to make one
allegation and he will be hunted down. To the male victim, it feels
as if society has declared open season on men and he is utterly
isolated and alone. He knows that if he gets his abuser to leave and
his abuser contests custody of the children, there is a 98% chance
she will get custody in the family courts. The family courts
regularly hand children over to abusive women because they believe
that the child being with the mother is in the best interests of the
child. This is despite the fact that they also know that 62% of all
child abuse is carried out by mothers!
Men are not
stupid. They read these things in the press and on the Internet and
they know that reporting abusers is a waste of time. They will not be
believed and, even if they are believed by the police on the spot,
somewhere down the line another official will take the kids and hand
them to the abuser. Some men report, as alluded to before, that when
they called the police about their abusive spouse they themselves
were arrested and thrown out of the home. That is also abuse!
A constant
tactic of female abusers is to throw the man out of the family home.
In my own relationship I was thrown out of the home by my partner 34
times in three years. Sometimes twice in one day. There was no
official way that I could have received any help. Had I not been able
to return to my own council house I would have been homeless as I
have no family. That could not happen in the case of a female victim.
Men know this. The way the system is set up at the moment, male
victims have no recourse what so ever and, if there are children
involved, things are even worse.
There is huge
personal shame involved for all abuse victims but for men, it is
often almost impossible to tell others that your wife or girlfriend
is beating you up. Men are known to lie to hospital staff about how
they got their injuries because they cannot bring themselves to
admit, "the little woman" caused them. They will also often self
treat their injuries at home as I did mine. Shame is primarily why
most men do not speak out about their abuse until they simply cannot
bare it any more and are forced to.
We must
impose a criminal standard of proof when allegations are made by
anyone claiming abuse. We must prosecute abusers who make false and
malicious allegations, often under oath in court rooms, to the
fullest extent of the law as a signal that we will not tolerate it
anymore. We must make abuse in the home a criminal offence and
prosecute abusers rigorously. Thus removing the need for judges in
the civil family courts to make decisions based on what is often
little more than hearsay evidence. We must help men to speak out. We
must find ways to tear down the barriers to speaking out. We must
believe men when they do speak out and then investigate the claims
made to prove their validity. We must channel resources into caring
for them when they speak out. We must give them safe places to run to
with their kids.
We can help
men to speak out by speaking to them about their experiences.
By acknowledging them as valid and important. By being prepared to
listen, we can change the lives of many, many people; because a
victim is a victim no matter what their race, gender or creed. Most
importantly, and before any of this is done, we must challenge or own
anti male prejudices.
Finally, we
must educate ourselves about female perpetrators. Then, we must
educate the public.
All of these
are the aims of ManKind, the men's charity I am here to represent
today. Give us your support. Work with us. Listen to us. Help us to
help you make a real difference to all victims of
domestic violence, irrespective of their age, colour, creed or
gender.